All insights

AI answer audits

How to read a GEO report without being sold a ranking

Seven numbers appear in most AI visibility reports. Four of them mean something. Here is how to tell which is which before you renew.

A grid of tracked questions scored across answer engines

The owner’s takeaway

A report should let you reproduce its claims. If it cannot show the questions, the runs, the window and the sources, the headline number is decoration.

AI visibility reporting borrowed the vocabulary of SEO and lost the rigour on the way. Agencies publish a “visibility score” with no denominator, a trend line with no sample, and a competitor chart with no question set.

You do not need to become a measurement expert to read one. You need four disclosures, and the willingness to ask for them.

Four questions before you renew

  1. Ask

    Questions and runs

    Full set, engines, runs per question.

  2. Ask

    Window and date

    Which days, rolling or fixed.

  3. Ask

    Sources

    URLs, not a count.

  4. Rerun

    Check one question

    Pick the most commercial one.

A vendor that cannot answer these is selling a feeling.

The four disclosures that make a number checkable

  1. The question set, in full, with the city and treatment.
  2. The engines and the number of runs per question.
  3. The window: which days, and whether it is rolling.
  4. The cited sources, with URLs, not just a count.

With those four, you can rerun the test yourself and land within a few points. Without them, you are reading a vendor's opinion with a percentage sign attached.

Which numbers matter, and which are theatre

Mention rate and share of voice matter because they are ratios with a stated denominator. Citation share matters because it shows whether the answer can be verified by a patient. Accuracy matters because a practice can be named and still be described wrongly, which is worse than silence.

A single “visibility score” out of 100 usually combines those four with weights nobody publishes. It is useful for a dashboard, not for a decision, and it should never be the only number in a renewal conversation.

Five red flags

  • A percentage with no sample size.
  • A trend line with fewer than three months behind it.
  • Screenshots without a date, the prompt, or the engine name.
  • Competitor charts that do not say which competitors.
  • A promise of placement, phrased as a target.

Your next move

Compare our report format with yours

The method page lists the formulas and the sampling rules. The snapshot applies them to five questions at no cost.

Free AI snapshotSee the numbers we publish